The most important facts at a glance
- The constitutional complaint is an extraordinary legal remedy to enforce the freedoms guaranteed by fundamental rights
- Strict admissibility requirements and deadlines must be observed
- Professional legal support significantly increases the chances of success
As a citizen in Germany, you enjoy the protection of our Basic Law. But what do you do if you feel that your constitutionally guaranteed rights have been violated and you have exhausted all other legal options? In such cases, the last legal remedy available to you is a constitutional complaint. In this article, we explain the most important requirements for a constitutional complaint and show you how we can support you in this complex procedure.
What is a constitutional complaint?
A constitutional complaint is an extraordinary legal remedy that you can use to appeal directly to the Federal Constitutional Court if you believe that the state - whether through laws, administrative acts or court decisions - has violated your fundamental rights or rights equivalent to fundamental rights. This is a powerful instrument for protecting your constitutional rights, but it is subject to strict conditions.
When can a constitutional complaint be considered?
Typically, our clients consider a constitutional complaint if they feel that their fundamental rights have been violated by government measures and have already exhausted all other legal avenues. This may be the case, for example, with laws that are perceived to be unconstitutional, administrative acts that disproportionately interfere with fundamental rights or court decisions that do not take sufficient account of fundamental rights aspects.
Central requirements for a constitutional complaint
The right to lodge a complaint is a fundamental requirement. You must be able to demonstrate that you yourself are currently and directly affected in your fundamental rights or rights equivalent to fundamental rights. General dissatisfaction with a government measure is not sufficient.
The principle of subsidiarity states that the constitutional complaint is the last resort (ultima ratio).
You must first exhaust all legal remedies. You must prove that you have already exhausted all other available legal remedies. As a rule, this includes the entire appeal process up to the highest competent court. By way of exception, the so-called constitutional complaint can be used to take direct action against laws if there is no legal recourse or it is unreasonable to go through it. If legal recourse has not been exhausted, the constitutional complaint is inadmissible.
It also follows from the principle of subsidiarity that the violation of fundamental rights must already be objected to in proceedings before specialized courts. If no fundamental rights complaint is lodged in the instance, the constitutional complaint is also inadmissible.
Compliance with the statutory deadline is also crucial. The constitutional complaint must be lodged within one month of service, pronouncement or notification of the last court decision. A constitutional complaint against a law, i.e. a constitutional complaint against a statute, must be lodged within one year of its entry into force.
The form and content of the complaint are also of great importance. The constitutional complaint must be submitted in writing and contain a detailed statement of grounds. You must demonstrate that the admissibility requirements have been met and which fundamental right has been violated by which measure and in what way. A precise constitutional argumentation is essential.
The path to the Federal Constitutional Court: Our approach
We understand that the path to the Federal Constitutional Court is often characterized by frustration and uncertainty. Many of our clients have already been through a long legal process and see the constitutional complaint as their last chance for justice. We take your concerns seriously and offer you competent support at every stage of the proceedings.
Our approach begins with an in-depth case analysis. First, we check with you whether the admissibility requirements are even met. We then thoroughly examine your case for its constitutional relevance and develop tailor-made lines of argument. Based on our in-depth knowledge of the case law of the Federal Constitutional Court, we develop a strategy that maximizes your chances of success. When drafting the notice of appeal, we focus on a clear and convincing presentation of the unconstitutionality. We remain in close contact with you throughout the entire process and keep you informed of all developments.
Why us?
Our law firm has many years of experience and success in the field of constitutional complaints. We have already represented numerous clients in complex constitutional law issues and have been able to assert our clients' interests in several cases.
Our strengths lie in our in-depth expertise in constitutional law, our many years of experience with constitutional complaints, our transparent communication about the prospects of success and risks, and our dedicated commitment to your rights.
The process of a constitutional complaint
The typical process of a constitutional complaint begins with an initial consultation and case analysis. In a detailed initial consultation, we analyze your case and examine its fundamental suitability for a constitutional complaint. We then carry out a detailed legal examination and draw up a concept for the constitutional complaint.
Once the mandate has been granted, we begin immediately with the careful drafting of the notice of appeal in close consultation with you. We submit the completed complaint to the Federal Constitutional Court in due time. We represent you throughout the proceedings and respond to any queries from the court. Finally, the Federal Constitutional Court decides on the acceptance and, if necessary, the merits of your complaint.
Practical tips for a successful constitutional complaint
To increase your chances of a successful constitutional complaint, you should carefully collect all relevant documents and decisions and strictly adhere to the specified deadlines. Consult a suitable lawyer for constitutional law at an early stage while you are still in the ordinary legal process. Together with your lawyer, he or she will prepare the constitutional complaint and finally explain which specific fundamental right has been violated and how.
The constitutional complaint as a last resort to protect your fundamental rights
The constitutional complaint is a powerful instrument for protecting your fundamental rights, but also a complex legal procedure with high hurdles. In view of the strict requirements and the often far-reaching consequences, professional legal support is essential.
We understand the importance of your case and the emotional strain that can accompany such proceedings. We use our expertise and experience to represent your rights before the highest German court.
If you believe that your fundamental rights have been violated and are considering a constitutional complaint, please do not hesitate to contact us. We offer you advice and assistance - for the best possible protection of your constitutional rights.
Frequently asked questions
A constitutional complaint is an extraordinary legal remedy that citizens can use to appeal to the Federal Constitutional Court if they believe that the state has violated their fundamental rights. It serves to protect constitutionally guaranteed rights.
You can lodge a constitutional complaint if you believe that your fundamental rights have been violated by a state measure, a law or a court decision and you have exhausted all other legal options.
As a rule, you must submit the constitutional complaint within one month of service, pronouncement or notification of the last court decision. In the case of a constitutional complaint against a law, the deadline is one year after the law comes into force.
A lawyer is not absolutely necessary for a constitutional complaint, but is strongly recommended due to the complexity of the procedure and the high legal requirements. You only need to be represented in the event of an oral hearing.
Proceedings before the Federal Constitutional Court are generally free of charge. However, legal fees are incurred, the amount of which depends on the individual case and the complexity of the proceedings. If the proceedings are successful, you can claim reimbursement of the costs incurred in accordance with the German Lawyers' Fees Act (Rechtsanwaltsvergütungsgesetz).
The chances of success are generally low, as the Federal Constitutional Court examines strict admissibility requirements. However, with professional legal support and a well-founded case, the chances can increase significantly.
The duration can vary greatly, from a few months to several years. In interim injunction proceedings, decisions are made quickly. In ordinary proceedings, it usually takes several years before a decision is reached.
You can lodge a constitutional complaint against laws, administrative acts and court decisions if these violate your fundamental rights or rights equivalent to fundamental rights.
If a constitutional complaint is successful, the Federal Constitutional Court can annul the challenged measure or decision. In the case of laws, it can declare them unconstitutional and null and void.
Yes, after exhausting national legal remedies, including an unsuccessful constitutional complaint, you can, under certain conditions, turn to the European Court of Human Rights.
German 
English